| Grade | Content |
| A | The summary, AI discussion, testability discussion, and criticisms are all present, well-written, and convey a reasonably good understanding of the ideas in the book |
| B | Good overall, but somewhat lacking in some of the above criteria |
| C | Serious deficiencies in some of the above criteria |
| D | Serious deficiencies in all criteria, or one or more required elements is missing |
| F | Paper is severely deficient or is not submitted |